Does Ellie need Redemption?

Does Ellie need Redemption in part 3 , since Ellie at the end is peace with Joel and she got that closure with her relationship with Joel , she is wearing Dina's bracelet , Typical in TLOU by analysing Abby and Joel's story that redemption is required due to lack of closure of character's relationship

In my opinion , Ellie got that closure and then I think Ellie doesnt need any redemption since she achieved that stage

I don't understand why some people pushing for like redemption of Ellie for what I don't understand , Vaccine plot by forgiving Joel Ellie already let go of it and since Ellie wearing Dina's bracelet we can atleast some what understand that Ellie is in path of reparing their relationship , I don't think that it's big thing or drama for Ellie otherwise she wouldn't have wear Dina's bracelet.

Redemption of Ellie is not worth part 3 because Ellie got that closure at the end of the game , she doesnt need to achieve anything and also Ellie is on way of repairing relationship with Dina and that's not that big thing since she is wearing bracelet.