Suede Jacket Dilemma

I’ve been looking at Olive suede jackets and narrowed it down to (a) Todd Snyder Dylan vs (b) Officine Generale Liam (made famous by Ryan Reynolds).

TS: snap buttons, calf leather, lined only in arms, heavier weight

OG: traditional buttons, goat leather, fully lined, lighter weight

Snap buttons are easier but I’m not sure how often I’ll button this jacket; plus, the snap buttons look cheaper imo.

I’ve read that goat leather is better quality than calf; fwiw, the calf leather on the OG feels better.

I don’t have a strong preference regarding the lining.

The TS feels much heavier but I’m not sure it’s warmer.

The OG styling and details are better.

Any advice? Anyone have the OG suede jacket?

I’m on the fence and need help deciding. If anyone has experience with the OG jacket, then that would be great.

Edit: pics now added below. Pic with dark button down is TS; white shirt is OG.