Rosewood Mayakoba or open to other suggestions

My husband and I are planning a 15th wedding anniversary trip in June. We can only go for three nights due to childcare, going Thursday-Sunday. We are flying out of Chicago and are currently thinking about Rosewood Mayakoba (questions about that below) but are also open to other suggestions within a 4-5 hour flight to Chicago.

We enjoy fine dining and pretty much just plan on relaxing and spending time together. Not looking for tons of activities.

Rosewood Mayakoba questions:

1) We are struggling with which room to pick: Deluxe Overwater Lagoon View Suite, Rooftop Ocean View Suite, and Beachfront Studio Suite. We will likely spend a decent amount of time in the suite and plunge pool. I love the idea of an ocean view, but folks also seem to really like the lagoon views.

2) We are using a TA and they have a concierge service where they can arrange our transportation, make our reservations, etc, but for $550. They said they could also introduce us to the concierge team and we can book directly, which option would you suggest?

Thanks!