Caleb…

The only reason Caleb is given a pass by everyone is because every other man this season was deranged. Caleb repeatedly brushed Mariah off when she tried to discuss his trial relationship with Aria. It would’ve taken ONE good, long conversation to clear the air and give her some reassurance about everything, but he couldn’t even do that. He wanted Aria to lie to Mariah about her experience and continued to interact with Aria despite Mariah’s wishes. You can’t use the “he wanted to tell Mariah about the connection himself” argument, because after a year later he STILL didn’t tell Mariah everything. He wasn’t being respectful - he was straight up lying to protect himself. I am not saying that Caleb was planning to leave Mariah for Aria, or even planning to leave Mariah at all, but let’s be serious here.

This sub continuously attacking Aria for being the only honest about everything is baffling.