Is the public out ot touch with LE salaries?

Had a guy in another subreddit boldly proclaim that "10th year police officers in affluent towns make $200,000 a year". While I realize salaries vary from agency to agency and overtime can add up this struck me as very unlikely. I asked him for evidence and he showed me some breakdown by township in NJ of salary levels which didn't prove his point. It degraded from there as he claimed this was something that "everybody knows".

Am I in the dark here? I have to imagine that salary for those many years in LE is extremely rare absent some extreme factors.